Table of Contents
Introduction
Overview of the 2nd Global Enterprise Blockchain Benchmarking Study
Importance of blockchain in modern industries
Blockchain Adoption Trends in 2019
2.1 Enterprise Blockchain Maturity
2.2 Industry-Specific Adoption: Financial Services Leading the Way
2.3 Long-Term Development Timelines
Key Findings from the Study
3.1 Centralization vs. Decentralization in Blockchain Networks
3.2 The Rise of Private, Permissioned Distributed Ledger Technology (DLT)
3.3 Dominant Blockchain Platforms: Hyperledger, Corda, MultiChain
Use Cases and Applications
4.1 Financial Services: Banking, Insurance, and Asset Trading
4.2 Supply Chain Management and Tracking
4.3 Certification and Compliance
Challenges and Barriers to Broader Adoption
5.1 Regulatory and Compliance Issues
5.2 Scalability, Security, and Performance Challenges
5.3 Misconceptions and “Blockchain Meme” Projects
Future Outlook and Industry Evolution
Gradual Decentralization of Blockchain Networks
Emergence of New Business Models and Revenue Generation Opportunities
Conclusion
Summary of key insights
Strategic recommendations for businesses adopting blockchain
1. Introduction
As the global business landscape becomes increasingly digitized, blockchain technology has emerged as a vital tool for industries looking to streamline processes, enhance security, and foster collaboration. The "2nd Global Enterprise Blockchain Benchmarking Study, 2019" provides a comprehensive analysis of the state of blockchain adoption across sectors, particularly focusing on how enterprises are leveraging distributed ledger technology (DLT) to solve critical business challenges. This report builds on the findings of the first study in 2017, revealing that while initial blockchain projects were experimental in nature, many have since evolved into mature, production-ready networks.
This article delves into the findings of the study, highlighting key trends in enterprise blockchain adoption, the specific industries leading the charge, and the technologies driving innovation. By examining the challenges that remain and looking at the future of blockchain, this piece aims to equip business leaders and decision-makers with the insights necessary to navigate this rapidly evolving landscape.
2. Blockchain Adoption Trends in 2019
2.1 Enterprise Blockchain Maturity
Between 2017 and 2019, the enterprise blockchain landscape underwent significant shifts, as revealed by the Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance's (CCAF) study. Blockchain, which once existed in the realm of speculative proofs-of-concept, has begun to demonstrate its value in real-world applications. In fact, the report notes that a growing number of blockchain networks have moved beyond the experimentation phase and into full production environments. This shift toward maturity is evident across multiple industries, particularly in financial services, where blockchain’s potential to eliminate inefficiencies and reduce operational costs is most apparent.
Despite the move towards production, the adoption of blockchain remains a gradual and complex process. The report found that the median enterprise blockchain project takes about 25 months to move from proof-of-concept to deployment. This extended timeline highlights the challenges enterprises face in implementing blockchain at scale, including regulatory hurdles, technical complexities, and the need for cross-organizational collaboration.
2.2 Industry-Specific Adoption: Financial Services Leading the Way
The financial services industry continues to lead blockchain adoption, accounting for 43% of live enterprise blockchain networks in production. This sector's dominance can be attributed to the blockchain’s ability to enhance transparency, reduce fraud, and streamline complex processes such as cross-border payments and trade finance. Major financial institutions have been early adopters, leveraging permissioned blockchain networks to ensure data integrity while maintaining control over sensitive information.
Other sectors, such as supply chain management and healthcare, have also begun to explore blockchain's potential, though they lag behind financial services in terms of adoption. The ability to track products in real-time, ensure provenance, and manage compliance makes blockchain an attractive option for these industries, especially as global supply chains become increasingly complex.
2.3 Long-Term Development Timelines
One of the key findings of the report is the long timeline required for blockchain networks to move from the initial exploration phase to full production. On average, enterprise blockchain projects spend approximately two-thirds of their time in the proof-of-concept and pilot phases before moving into production. Large-scale blockchain networks, particularly those involving multiple stakeholders, often take more than four years to reach full deployment. This extended development period underscores the need for patience and a long-term commitment from enterprises aiming to integrate blockchain into their operations.
3. Key Findings from the Study
3.1 Centralization vs. Decentralization in Blockchain Networks
Although blockchain is often associated with decentralization, the study reveals that most enterprise blockchain networks remain highly centralized in their current form. A staggering 81% of the networks analyzed have a dominant leader entity overseeing governance, with many also relying on third-party providers to operate nodes. While centralization may offer efficiency in the early stages of a project, the report indicates that there is a general expectation that control will gradually be distributed over time as networks mature.
3.2 The Rise of Private, Permissioned Distributed Ledger Technology (DLT)
The study highlights the growing preference for private, permissioned blockchain networks in enterprise settings. These networks, unlike public blockchains such as Bitcoin or Ethereum, restrict access to trusted participants and are designed to meet the specific needs of businesses, particularly in regulated industries like finance and healthcare. By leveraging permissioned DLT systems, organizations can maintain control over their data while benefiting from the transparency and security blockchain provides.
3.3 Dominant Blockchain Platforms: Hyperledger, Corda, MultiChain
The report identifies Hyperledger Fabric, Corda, and MultiChain as the most widely adopted blockchain platforms for enterprise use, with Hyperledger Fabric leading the pack. The flexibility of these platforms, combined with their ability to support private networks and smart contracts, makes them well-suited to the needs of enterprises looking to deploy scalable blockchain solutions. Hyperledger Fabric, in particular, is used by 48% of the projects surveyed, further solidifying its position as the go-to platform for enterprise blockchain development.
4. Use Cases and Applications
4.1 Financial Services: Banking, Insurance, and Asset Trading
The financial services sector continues to dominate enterprise blockchain adoption, as reflected in the report’s findings. Banking institutions, insurance companies, and trading platforms have been early adopters due to blockchain’s potential to enhance operational efficiency, reduce fraud, and improve transparency in transactional processes. One of the key use cases for blockchain in this sector is cross-border payments, where blockchain solutions offer faster settlement times and lower fees compared to traditional payment networks.
Additionally, blockchain has been employed in trade finance, where the need for a tamper-resistant, transparent ledger can streamline processes like the issuance of letters of credit and trade documentation. In asset trading, blockchain allows for tokenization of assets, including real estate and securities, making it easier to trade these assets on a blockchain platform while ensuring compliance with regulations. These use cases demonstrate blockchain’s ability to improve the infrastructure of financial markets, increasing speed and security while reducing costs.
4.2 Supply Chain Management and Tracking
The report highlights supply chain management as one of the most promising areas for blockchain adoption outside of financial services. Blockchain’s capability to create an immutable, transparent ledger for tracking goods from production to delivery makes it invaluable for industries where provenance and authenticity are critical. Use cases include tracking raw materials, ensuring that products meet regulatory compliance, and even combating fraud by proving the authenticity of high-value goods like diamonds or luxury goods.
By using blockchain, companies can establish a real-time record of a product's journey through the supply chain, from supplier to end consumer. This is particularly useful in sectors such as food and pharmaceuticals, where ensuring the safety and origin of products is paramount. The report indicates that 19% of live blockchain networks are being used for supply chain tracking, highlighting the growing role of blockchain in optimizing complex, multi-party logistics.
4.3 Certification and Compliance
Certification and compliance are other key areas where blockchain technology is making a significant impact, as outlined in the report. By leveraging blockchain’s tamper-evident properties, organizations can issue and verify certifications and licenses in a more efficient and secure manner. For example, industries that require strict regulatory compliance, such as pharmaceuticals, can use blockchain to ensure that all products meet industry standards before they reach the market.
Blockchain can also streamline compliance processes by automating the verification of transactions, ensuring that all parties adhere to established protocols and regulations. This eliminates the need for manual checks, which are often time-consuming and prone to human error. In industries like healthcare and finance, where compliance is critical, blockchain offers a transparent and auditable record, helping businesses meet their regulatory obligations.
5. Challenges and Barriers to Broader Adoption
Despite the growing adoption of blockchain technology across various sectors, the report identifies several key challenges that are hindering broader implementation. These include regulatory uncertainties, technical limitations, and the pervasive issue of misconceptions surrounding blockchain’s capabilities.
5.1 Regulatory and Compliance Issues
One of the most significant barriers to enterprise blockchain adoption is regulatory uncertainty. Many countries have yet to establish clear guidelines on how blockchain networks should operate, especially when it comes to the use of cryptocurrencies, tokenized assets, and decentralized financial systems. The lack of regulatory clarity creates a risk for companies, particularly in heavily regulated industries like finance and healthcare, where compliance with local laws is critical.
The report notes that blockchain’s decentralized nature often clashes with existing regulatory frameworks, which are designed to oversee centralized entities. As blockchain networks mature and move into production, businesses must navigate a complex web of local, national, and international regulations. Until more standardized regulatory frameworks are established, this uncertainty will continue to be a significant obstacle to widespread blockchain adoption.
5.2 Scalability, Security, and Performance Challenges
In addition to regulatory challenges, technical limitations remain a key hurdle for blockchain networks, particularly in the areas of scalability, security, and performance. While blockchain is celebrated for its transparency and immutability, the technology struggles to scale in a way that supports high transaction volumes without compromising performance. For instance, public blockchains like Ethereum often suffer from network congestion, leading to slower transaction times and higher fees.
The report also highlights the need for improved security protocols. Although blockchain itself is secure, the surrounding infrastructure, such as smart contracts and decentralized applications (dApps), can be vulnerable to hacking. Furthermore, the reliance on third-party nodes and hosting services for enterprise blockchain networks introduces additional security risks that need to be managed carefully.
5.3 Misconceptions and “Blockchain Meme” Projects
A unique finding from the report is the existence of what it refers to as “blockchain meme” projects—initiatives that claim to be blockchain-based but lack the key characteristics that define true distributed ledger systems. These projects often use blockchain technology in name only, relying on traditional centralized architectures while capitalizing on the blockchain hype.
This creates confusion among businesses and stakeholders, as the distinction between genuine blockchain solutions and so-called “blockchain meme” projects becomes blurred. The report suggests that these misconceptions are hindering the technology’s growth by leading companies to either adopt unsuitable solutions or dismiss blockchain entirely due to its association with overhyped, underperforming projects. Educating decision-makers about the true capabilities of blockchain technology will be critical to overcoming this barrier.
6. Future Outlook and Industry Evolution
Looking ahead, the 2nd Global Enterprise Blockchain Benchmarking Study offers an optimistic view of blockchain’s future, despite the challenges identified. As blockchain networks continue to mature and businesses gain a deeper understanding of the technology’s potential, there is growing anticipation of blockchain’s role in reshaping industries.
One key trend highlighted in the report is the gradual decentralization of enterprise blockchain networks. While most live networks are currently centralized, with a dominant leader overseeing governance, there is an expectation that control will be distributed over time as the technology evolves. This move toward decentralization will not only enhance the resilience of blockchain networks but also make them more transparent and secure.
The report also anticipates the emergence of new business models and revenue generation opportunities enabled by blockchain. In the early stages, most blockchain networks focused on reducing operational costs through improved reconciliation processes. However, as these networks mature, they are expected to create entirely new markets and services, from tokenized asset trading to decentralized financial services (DeFi).
Ultimately, the future of blockchain will depend on the ability of businesses to navigate regulatory challenges, overcome technical limitations, and educate stakeholders about the true value of distributed ledger technology. Those that succeed will be well-positioned to capitalize on the opportunities that blockchain offers in creating more efficient, secure, and transparent business processes.
7. Conclusion
The 2nd Global Enterprise Blockchain Benchmarking Study provides valuable insights into the state of enterprise blockchain adoption in 2019, highlighting both the progress made and the challenges that remain. With financial services leading the charge, blockchain technology is beginning to demonstrate its value in reducing costs, improving transparency, and enabling new business models across various industries.
However, the road to widespread adoption is fraught with challenges, including regulatory uncertainty, technical limitations, and misconceptions surrounding blockchain’s true capabilities. As these barriers are addressed, blockchain’s potential to transform industries will become increasingly evident.
For businesses looking to embrace blockchain, the key takeaway is that a long-term commitment is essential. Blockchain projects require patience, careful planning, and a willingness to adapt to an evolving regulatory and technical landscape. Those that invest the time and resources into understanding and implementing blockchain technology today will be the ones driving innovation tomorrow.
Access the 2nd Global Enterprise Blockchain Benchmarking Study Report
Comments